-
Posted by Katherine Carson on Jul 2, 2009

Could Zimbabwe’s diamonds be considered ‘blood diamonds’? According to a recently released report by Human Right’s Watch entitled “Diamonds in the Rough” the answer is yes. The report claims that since last year the Zimbabwean Army, controlled by ZANU-PF, the party of embattled President Robert Mugabe, has used violent and illegal methods to control the diamond mines in the Marange district in eastern Zimbabwe.
On the surface, the army’s decision to retake control of the diamond fields in October 2008 appeared legitimate. The state media depicted the military operation, called No Return, as an attempt to restore order and control to the lawless area. But in reality the operation was simply a way to access a previously untapped source of riches. The revenue gained from selling the diamonds has been used by ZANU-PF to maintain and reinforce their control over the army, which began to slip at the end of last year when soldiers rioted in Harare over their low salaries.
From the start, the army’s actions in Marange have been violent. During Operation No Return the army killed over 400 miners, shooting many of them from helicopters, and then dumping their bodies into unmarked graves. Since taking control of the area, the army has used members of the community as slave labor. Men, women, and children have been forced to work in the diamond fields and one witness stated that “if anyone resists, they risk torture, beatings or even death.” It is an intolerable situation that seems set to continue as the army and ZANU-PF officials continue to profit from selling the diamonds. It is a profit Human Rights Watch argues that could be used, if properly regulated, by Zimbabwe’s unity government to rebuild the country.
Yet Zimbabwe’s diamonds cannot officially, according to the Kimberley Process, be classified as ‘blood diamonds.’ The Kimberley Process was originally created to sever the link between the diamond trade, which was being used by rebel groups to fund their activities, and violent conflicts. Since Zimbabwe’s diamonds are being mined and sold by partners in the unity government – not a rebel group – they do not explicitly meet the Kimberley Process criteria for what constitutes a “blood diamond.” Experts, however, have been publically critical of the narrowness of the Kimberley Process. Talking about Zimbabwean diamonds, Ian Smillie, considered the ‘grandfather’ of the Kimberley Process expressed a strong opinion on the matter: “They are blood diamonds, they have blood all over them,” he said recently. Smillie and some nonprofit groups are lobbying to have Zimbabwe suspended from the Kimberley Process.
A team of representatives from the Kimberley Process is currently in Zimbabwe assessing the situation, and deciding whether or not the government is complying with the group’s standards. If the detailed evidence presented by Human Rights Watch factors into the team’s findings, it will be surprising if they conclude that diamonds from the Marange fields are even remotely “conflict free.” However, it remains to be seen how far parties to the process are willing to go. The Human Rights Watch report lobbies officials to expand the Kimberley Process criteria to include diamonds that fund violence and corruption on the part of government officials as well as non-state actors, but no such movement was made during a recent conference on the Kimberley Process in Namibia where the situation in Zimbabwe topped the agenda.
Rebecca Brocato contributed to this post.
Photo: Diamond mine in Marange. AP via Human Rights Watch
Recent Publications
- Jun 22, 2009Advocacy | Darfur and Southern Sudan | Maggie Fick | Peace | Prevention | Strategy Papers
- Jun 10, 2009Adam O'Brien | Darfur and Southern Sudan | Genocide | Peace | Prevention | Protection | Strategy Papers
- May 13, 2009Darfur and Southern Sudan | Eastern Congo | John Prendergast | Sexual Violence | Speeches and Testimonies | Violence Against Women
Upcoming Events
- Jul 7, 2009
LISTEN
Introducing the new Enough Podcast. This week we're taking a look back on World Refugee Day and the surrounding events. Enough Executive Director John Norris reminds us why Refugee Day matters and Enough Said blogger Laura Heaton reflects on some of the week's highlights.
LISTEN
It's been a busy couple of weeks for Sudan policy. To debrief on all of the action, Sudan activists joined Enough's John Prendergast and John Norris for a conference call. Didn't get the chance to join? Catch up with a recording of the call.
Lobby Congress To Help End the Conflict in Central Africa
|
|
VISIT "How It Ends" for more information on the event and to find how you can get involved.
READ The reaction to the LRA Bill, HR 2478, from Enough and other leading groups in the Human Rights community.
For more information on the Lord's Resistance Army and the conflict in Central Africa, visit our special LRA page.
From Mines To Mobile Phones
WATCH a slide show detailing how conflict minerals go from the mines of Congo to your cell phone, iPod, and other electronics products.
LISTEN
Recently Enough's Executive Director John Norris sat down with Bridget Conley-Zilkic of the U.S. Holocaust Museum to answer the big question: Can Genocide and Crimes Against Humanity be Ended?
Find the full podcast and a transcript here.
Check out Enough's Products
Subscribe to
Enough Said Blog
Enough Project E-newsletter
Try Enough's Week In Photos. See the most recent events along with Enough's policy recommendations and analysis. |
Obama on Genocide
READ a transcript of President Obama's keynote address at the Holocaust Memorial Museum’s Days of Remembrance ceremony. READ Laura Heaton's Blog post.
LEARN about the key Darfur advocates who attended the recent White House meeting with President Obama and his Special Envoy to Sudan General Scott Gration.
International Criminal Court
|
READ full coverage of the International Criminal Court action against Sudan President Omar al-Bashir. |
Join the Movement
Campaigns & Initiatives
![]() |
| RAISE Hope For Congo |
|
Take the Congo Challenge - RAISE awareness, RAISE your voice, RAISE the profile of the deadliest war in the world. And then challenge others to join the movement. More info |
![]() |
| Darfur Dream Team |
|
Check out the Sister Schools Program at our NEW Darfur Dream Team site. Pro-basketballer Tracy McGrady, Enough Project and partners are connecting schools and universities with students in the Darfuri refugee camps. |
![]() |
| Darfur Christian Action |
|
Enough, in partnership with the Church Communication Network, recently co-hosted a simulcast event highlighting the needs and opportunities for individuals and churches to get involved in ending the crisis in Sudan. The broadcast, originally shown in over 90 locations across North America, is now available online here. |
| Check out Enough's podcast page here. | ![]() |


Enough is joining forces with Invisible Children and Resolve Uganda for the "How it Ends Lobby Days," from June 22-23 in Washington, D.C.








